Collect the policy that was in force
Keep the declarations page, policy wording, and endorsements for the date of the incident. A renewal or a current online summary may describe different terms. The declarations page lists selected coverages and limits, but it usually does not contain every condition or exclusion.
Ask what is being decided
Read the decision letter for the claim number, the loss at issue, and the policy wording cited. If the insurer requests more information, make a list of the documents, who may have them, and the response date. A request for information is not necessarily a final denial. If the explanation was only verbal, ask for it in writing.
Track deadlines and amounts separately
Record the dates of letters and any dates the insurer asks you to meet. Keep estimates, proof of payment, benefit statements, and prior offers together. A policy limit is not a promise that the entire limit will be paid. A deductible, valuation issue, exclusion, or another policy may affect the amount in dispute.
Questions worth taking to a lawyer
Which policy language is the insurer relying on? Is it disputing coverage, fault, the extent of the loss, or all three? Has a settlement or release been proposed? Bring the full correspondence, not just the latest page. The insurance commissioner also publishes consumer information about how to raise insurance questions.